Anonymous commented at 2013-07-09 03:13:20 » #1356353

Really, shouldn't this picture or any other of Mariandale be tagged ether Futanari or at the very least NewHalf? She says she's female right? So its the same as Poison. Tagging it "Trap" is saying she's a feminine boy, and trust me if you called any transgendered females a "feminine boy" you're be in for a world of hurt!
~Belial~

12 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2013-07-18 19:47:54 » #1362609

Yeah, and calling most fat people "fat" pisses them off, too. Doesn't change the fact that they ARE fat.

11 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2013-07-20 21:06:20 » #1363947

@Anon2
There's a difference between the two subjects. Though its true she was born a male, however since she's gone to the lengths of gaining breast anyone should accept her as female or at least newhalf.
Now then, since I've once more stated my opinion that you should respect her beliefs of being a female, lets get on to the actual problem I had.
The Tag. Traps are male that have the appearance of females. Thats it. They look like girls but are not girls. There for a character who classifies herself as a female is not a trap. That was my problem, not with the character, nor the picture but instead with the tags.
~Belial~

2 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2013-07-20 21:26:23 » #1363955

^ But for tagging purposes, what the character considers him/herself is totally irrelevant.

Just because he classifies himself as a female doesn't make him a biological woman. He may be convincing as a woman, but he's still a male for tagging purposes unless he's fully transitioned, and a man that makes a convincing woman is.... a trap.

I do think that the newhalf tag applies, though, as far as my understanding of it goes, since he does have breasts. Futanari, however, I don't think applies, because he'd need a vagina for that, I believe.

But honestly, it's probably up to the mods to decide which tags we should be using for him.

4 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2013-08-30 23:42:39 » #1389781

Fucking HELL, would you get over your persecution complex? This hair splitting has been going on for over a year now, and the trap tag has basically been ruined because of it.

2 Points Flag

Anonymous commented at 2013-10-02 00:55:48 » #1409214

She doesn't need no nasty vag.

2 Points Flag

sdibolcrif commented at 2013-10-08 00:40:28 » #1412792

I do gotta agree with anon1 - do we tag Poison with "1boy" or "male_only"?

1 Points Flag

sdibolcrif commented at 2013-10-08 00:44:07 » #1412794

Fuck, forgot there's no edit function here.

Anyway. No, we don't. We've been using feminine tags for her since before IS even existed.

So why is Mariandale different?

2 Points Flag