Notice: My personal stance on AI generated artwork. Retweet and share if you agree. Let us discuss, and not immediately scream bloody murder.

Now Viewing: Doujinshi Images?
Keep it civil, do not flame or bait other users. If you notice anything illegal or inappropriate being discussed, contact an administrator or moderator.

Rsrx - Group: Member - Total Posts: 7
user_avatar
Doujinshi Images?
Posted on: 05/10/19 05:52AM

TOS states: "Doujinshi/Manga/Light Novels: Do not upload these. Comic strips are fine (4koma), as are the covers of Doujin only!"

Yet there is a ton of it here. What am I missing?



Jerl - Group: The Real Administrator - Total Posts: 6662
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/10/19 08:46AM

We have only a handful of active moderators, and there are more important things for us to be doing than tracking down doujin/manga pages.



Anti_Gendou - Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 4351
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/10/19 09:33AM

I actually wish covers were allowed if they still aren't. Especially if textless variants exist.



Jerl - Group: The Real Administrator - Total Posts: 6662
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/10/19 09:40AM

Doujin covers are allowed.



Rsrx - Group: Member - Total Posts: 7
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/10/19 07:41PM

Jerl said:
We have only a handful of active moderators, and there are more important things for us to be doing than tracking down doujin/manga pages.

Maybe recruit more mods then? Or maybe appoint some temporary ones? It wouldn't take too long for a few people to mass delete all the easily-spottable images. Also I would think that the rule should be tweaked a bit to allow full color/pages with a full-page drawing. I wouldn't think anyone wants Cle Masahiro's or Yang-Do's masterpieces to be removed.




jedi1357 - Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 5724
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/10/19 09:17PM

Rsrx said:

Maybe recruit more mods then? Or maybe appoint some temporary ones? It wouldn't take too long for a few people to mass delete all the easily-spottable images. Also I would think that the rule should be tweaked a bit to allow full color/pages with a full-page drawing. I wouldn't think anyone wants Cle Masahiro's or Yang-Do's masterpieces to be removed.



Art books that aren't really telling a narrative are still allowed. As for multi-page comics, our sister site thedoujin.com/index.php/categories/index was specially made to host these.



Len - Group: Member - Total Posts: 339
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/12/19 04:36PM

Rsrx said:
Jerl said:
We have only a handful of active moderators, and there are more important things for us to be doing than tracking down doujin/manga pages.

Maybe recruit more mods then?

Amazing idea; report rule-breaking posts to draw mod attention.



Chytharo - Group: Project Sponsor - Total Posts: 73
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/15/19 10:43AM

Btw. What about bonus one-page illustrations, that don't have anything to do with the rest of the work story-wise?
For example pictures like that: nhentai.net/g/202006/218/
To me it seems identical to what a lot of artists post on sites like pixiv for example.



Jerl - Group: The Real Administrator - Total Posts: 6662
user_avatar
Posted on: 05/15/19 11:33AM

If it's just an illustration, it's fine, even if it's part of a work that is mostly a comic. To be disallowed, the image itself has to be a comic. Non-comic artbooks are completely allowed, for example.



Hyoroemon - Group: Member - Total Posts: 40
user_avatar
Posted on: 10/31/23 07:54PM

Jerl said:
To be disallowed, the image itself has to be a comic. Non-comic artbooks are completely allowed, for example.

I remember reading somewhere that even cover is not allowed but i couln't find that rule here gelbooru.com/index.php?page=wiki&s=view&id=6645
Is cover allowed?



add_replyAdd Reply


1 2